Baseball teams as Simpsons characters

When one perceives true talent, the first reaction is to look on with awe. For some, this is followed by a second reaction in which they try to figure out how they can get a piece of the action.

Jimmy Guterman and Owen O’Donnell, The Worst Rock-and-Roll Records of All-Time, page 61.

Last week, I stumbled across an idea that struck me as both brilliant and original. The sports website Randall Simon’s Sausages decided to take a different kind of approach to its NFL season preview article. It matched up each NFL team with the Simpsons character it most closely resembled.

That article was a lot of fun. My first reaction upon reading it: What a great idea! Immediately following that was my second reaction: I’ve just got to rip off that idea sometime for THT when I’m stuck for a good column idea. And, of course, I quickly realized that I have no really wonderful column idea set to go for this week, so . . ..

For anyone looking for solid criteria and a consistent, logical rationale in determining what team got aligned with whichever Simpsons character—what the hell is wrong with you? Seriously. This is meant as fun. If you find it entertaining – great. If you find it insightful, uh, okay.

I’ll try the best I can to find matches that work, and when that fails try to do a good enough job BS’ing something that it sounds plausible enough. (And to think: Some people think a liberal arts education is worthless! HA!)

Here we go, division by division (and based on rank within the division as of Friday, when I sat down to write this), starting with the AL East:

New York Yankees: Montgomery Burns.

Well, duh. Do I even have to explain this comparison? Okay, fine. One is big, rich, evil and all-powerful. The other owns a nuclear power plant. Why yes that punch line was obvious. And yes I went there anyway.

Tampa Bay Rays: Professor John Frink

In recent years, Tampa has been one of the sharpest franchises in baseball. The Rays won a pennant despite playing in the toughest division in baseball’s superior league. Now enjoying their third straight winning season, they should return to the playoffs for the second time this year, despite having one of the lowest payrolls. In that regard, they’re a good match for the smartest man in Springfield.

That said, it’s hard for me to think of the franchise without recalling its first bungling decade of existence when it couldn’t do anything right. That also makes the Rays a good fit for Frink, who can’t remember to carry the one, even when it means warding off elementary chaos theory that tells us that all robots will eventually turn against their masters and run amok in an orgy of blood and kicking and the biting with the metal teeth and the hurting and shoving.

Boston Red Sox: Martin Prince.

I’m tempted to make this one Blinky the Three-Eyed Fish, because that was a major nemesis for Mr. Burns, but Boston deserves a match-up based on itself, not just the Yankees rivalry.

Cue Martin Prince. He’s a brainy high-achiever who is always expected to do well—just like the Red Sox. And some people find him just a bit annoying—just like with Red Sox nation.

Toronto Blue Jays: Frank Grimes

This is a team that’s just screwed. If the Jays work hard, do what their supposed to do, and follow the path that leads many other teams to promised land of the postseason, then their chances of making the playoffs rise up from non-existent to really lousy. That’s Frank Grimes for you, the perpetually screwed one-episode character. If any baseball team would be stuck living on top of one bowling alley and beneath another, it’s the Blue Jays.

Baltimore Orioles: Crazy Cat Lady

An utterly incoherent raving lunatic makes a pretty good comp for Peter Angelos.

Now for the AL Central:

Minnesota Twins: Waylon Smithers

The Twins are an effective and highly competent organization. Other teams may draw more attention, but the Twins are constantly doing the work that needs to be done. In that regard, they’re just like Smithers.

A Hardball Times Update
Goodbye for now.

Chicago White Sox: Krusty the Clown.

Krusty is crass, rude, ill-tempered, and obnoxious. Despite that—or perhaps because of it—he sure can be entertaining. In other words, he is one heckuva good match for Sox manager Ozzie Guillen. There’s a reason the Sox got a reality TV show for themselves.

That said, I can’t possibly imagine Ozzie Guillen hosting a TV show for kids. (But if he did, I would certainly watch!)

“Ahhh—I thought the Generals were due!”

Detroit Tigers: Sea Captain.

I dunno—I think Jim Leyland looks a little like the Sea Captain.

Want a better reason? . . . uh, . . ..the Sea Captain once commanded a ship of lost souls, and the Tigers are well out of the playoff race for this year.

He looks a little seasick.

Kansas City Royals: Ralph Wiggum

Ralph is a nice enough kid, but he sure isn’t the sharpest knife in the drawer. He’s always at or near the bottom of the class and you don’t really expect any more from him than that. Sounds like the Royals, who haven’t competed in a pennant race since before The Simpsons got their TV show. (But they have lost 100 games four times since then!)

Cleveland Indians: Poochie.

Here’s an assignment: Go back and read what people wrote about the Indians franchise a few/couple years ago. They were the hot young team that everyone was excited about. This isn’t just stat-nerds, either. They got a really big buildfup as a modern model franchise toward the end of The Yankee Years by Tom Verducci and Joe Torre. But they never really delivered, and as I write this they are stuck in baseball’s most embarrassing location: south of Kansas City in the standings.

Poochie was supposed to be the next big thing: the character that was going to shake up the Itchy and Scratchy Show. Didn’t happen. Really didn’t happen. At least the Indians got a division title out of their team, but then again at least the Simpsons got one good episode out of Poochie.

Finishing off the Junior Circuit is the AL West.

Texas Rangers: President George H. W. Bush.

Well, his son once owned the team after all . . .

He was in only one episode, but that might the best Simpsons episode of them all.

Oakland A’s: Sideshow Bob

He’s a genius. He’s got all these plans to meet his goals that always work on paper, but his success record isn’t so hot. How many times have you heard people call Billy Beane a genius? A bunch, I’m betting. His record isn’t so hot lately, though.

To be fair, Beane’s A’s had quite a nice stretch whereas all of Bob’s plans have been foiled. But I’m sure some Oakland fans feel the last four years are one endless string of rakes in the face.

Anaheim Angels: Bart Simpson

The Angels had a nice run as stars of the division, claiming five division titles in six years—and that’s aside from their wild card draw turned world championship. Now they’ve been swept aside by the Rangers.

Bart was the original focus of the Simpsons, but has since been swept aside by Homer, who is the real draw to the show.

Seattle Mariners: Comic Book Guy

Comic Book Guy seems intelligent, but ultimately he’s pretty lame. The Mariners front office people sound rather smart, but man they are having a rough go of it this year.

On to the NL:

Philadelphia Phillies: Rainier Wolfcastle.

Wolfcastle is the big, powerful movie star. The Phillies are the big, powerful offensive team. Okay, their homers are down this year, but they led the league in HR by a ton last year, and the year before, and came in second the year before that. That’s a good comp for the strongest man on The Simpsons.

Atlanta Braves: Lisa Simpson

She’s an achiever who always expects to do good, just like the Bobby Cox Braves.

Florida Marlins: Moe the Bartender

Moe is a sleazy, seedy ne’er-do-well. He’s got all sorts of questionable ways of making money, ranging from ripping off Homer’s cough syrup-inspired drink to various illegal activities involving killer whales. Heck, when Mr. Burns’ oil well ruined the atmosphere in his bazaar, he told patrons he’d have to charge them if they got high off the noxious oil fumes.

In other words, Moe is the best comp for Jeff Loria I can imagine. Though we all like to take shots at the owner of our favorite team, Loria really is in a class by himself.

That’s Loria, on the far left.

New York Mets: Lionel Hutz, attorney at law

They both should be so much better than they are. Hutz could be a respected attorney if he wasn’t such a drunk. And the Mets really should do better than desperately fighting for third.

Washington Nationals: Capital City Goofball

Some of these just write themselves.

Now for the NL Central.

Cincinnati Reds: Kang and Kodos

For a few years there, the Reds were a personal dark horse pick of mine (and I believe of a few others as well). I never really expected them to capture the division, but thought they were a team to look out for. I finally gave up on them not so long ago, and look at them now. They attacked and are taking over the NL Central.

Kang and Kodos were on the edge of the early Treehouse of Horror episodes, not really doing anything—just a bit ominously threatening. Just when you got used to them staying in the back, they attacked in the ’96 Treehouse of Horror episode.

St. Louis Cardinals: Artie Ziff

Ziff was the high school nerd back in the 1970s who later went on to become a super-success story. That said, while you had to respect Ziff’s success, he isn’t exactly a likable person.

The Cardinals also had a rough time of it back in the 1970s, but have done pretty well pretty much ever since. That said, more than a few people out there are more than a little bugged by Tony LaRussa.

Houston Astros: Lenny

The Astros aren’t much of a team, and haven’t been much of one for a while. Even when they perform respectably, it’s more a surprise than anything else. They’re good for a generic joke you want to make about a second-division team, and that’s about it these days.

Lenny is good for a joke (at his expense) and that’s it. Mr. Burns lost his power plant? You can get a nice joke with Homer saying “the bank put Lenny in charge.” If Homer has a nightmare about his future, you can get a chuckle out of President Lenny. Both the Astros and Lenny make an effective pathetic punch line.

Milwaukee Brewers: Fat Tony

How can the team featuring Prince Fielder not be matched with a character named Fat Tony?

Yes, it’s a cheap joke, but—well, okay.

Chicago Cubs: Homer Simpson

Homer Simpson is, among other things, absolutely incompetent at his job. One might even go so far as to say he’s historically bad at his job. The parallel to the team without a championship in 102 years should be obvious.

Incompetence aside, Homer is an easy man to please. Just give him some beer and he’s happy. Cubs fans have a reputation for low standards as well. They don’t require a quality team or hope for the future to fill Wrigley Field. Many are perfectly happy to enjoy the day at the ballpark drinking beer.

Mmmmmmm. . . . . beer

Pittsburgh Pirates: Barney Gumble.

The Pirates are a hopeless case if ever major league baseball ever had one. They are now in the midst of a record 18th consecutive losing season and barring a massive upsurge will end 2010 with their worst record in their entire 18-year streak. They’re so bad, they’ll drive their fans to the drunken, destitute depths of Barney Gumble.

It might be hard to remember, but the Pirates were once good. They even won two world championships in the 1970s. According to a Simpsons flashback episode, Barney once had a promising future, back when in the 1970s when he was in high school.

Lastly, the NL West.

San Diego Padres: Dr. Hibbard

Dr. Hibbard is not an especially flashy character, but he is good at his job. The Padres aren’t one of the game’s glamor franchises, but they are in first place. They’ve had only two losing seasons in the last seven (fine, they were two of the last three years). They’re a good match for Hibbard.

San Francisco Giants: Groundskeeper Willie

Willie used to be the ugliest man in Glasgow, and the Giants used to employ Bengie Molina. The Giants play in a nice ballpark, and that’s something Willie should know something about. After all, he is a groundskeeper (what’s more, he once told Bart that in summers and on weekends he works at a golf course as Greenskeeper Willie). So that’s why I match these two up.

Either that, or I was stuck for a match and just made up a comparison about Willie because I like the character. I consider either to be perfectly cromunlent reasons that embiggens the article.

Colorado Rockies: Ned Flanders

They Rockies are perhaps the MLB team most closely associated with Christianity. They’ve hosted Faith Nights at the ballpark, and some of their players are publicly Christian. Flanders, of course, is such a two-shoes so goody that his own minister is sick of him.

Los Angeles Dodgers: Mr. and Mrs. Van Houten

Though they’re back together now, the Van Houtens went through a nasty divorce. The Dodgers’ owners are about to experience all that misery for themselves.

Arizona Diamondbacks: Millhous Van Houten

Millhous looks up to his parents, and checking the standings the D-backs appear to be the only team in their division looking up to the Dodgers.

References & Resources
This whole thing would’ve never happened had it not been for the very entertaining NFL team preview piece at Randall Simon’s Sausages. Sorry for not including Youtube clips like that site did, but (1) I don’t know how to do it, and (2) even if I had, I probably would’ve ended up picking a lot of the same clips, which is a bit too much of a ripoff.

Opening quote comes from The Worst Rock-and-Roll Records of All-Time by Jimmy Guterman and Owen O’Donnell.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
13 years ago

And just like Krusty, the White Sox always seem to be better in the ratings/standings than you think they should be based on talent.  No matter how many times you think they are going to get cancelled or put on hiatus for retooling, theyu always seem to be competitive somehow.

Jason B
13 years ago

I heart this premise.  I snickered several times – no LOL-ing whilst reading at work. You just knocked this outta the park.

“[Former Prez GHW Bush] was in only one episode, but that might the best Simpsons episode of them all.”

Really?!? I always thought that show was a pretty weak entry in the midst of the show’s heyday. Just seemed overly gimmicky.  But reasonable minds can certainly differ.  smile

I would also submit Edna Krabbapel for the Mets – once something worth looking at, but now past their prime, and something of a train wreck. 

Under the same premise that you used for Smithers – not much flash but quietly efficient – I was thinking of Principal Skinner (Tamzarian?) for the Twins.

Finally I thought of Cletus for the Marlins – he has about seventeen cents to his name, Loria spends about seventeen dollars on his annual team payroll. Despite his thrift, Cletus had some occasionally talented offspring (they briefly formed a band managed by Lisa, then Krusty) like Loria occasionally fields some talented on-field product.

Jeffrey Gross
13 years ago

@Michael Caragliano: hahahahahaah

loved this piece

13 years ago

Nice piece, but I knew I was getting deja-vu as I was reading it.

Fun to compare the two lists.

If only General Disarray could have warned you.

Chris J.
13 years ago


Nice catch!  I should’ve guessed that my unoriginal idea was even less original than I guessed.

Jason –

Yeah, I love the W. episode.  Some really great moments “Who is Disco Stu?”  “Way to go Homer, cleverest thing you’ll ever say and no one heard you say it.”  “I’ll ruin you like a Japanese banquet.” 

Plus I liked how they handled the build up to the whole Homer-Bush rivalry – Homer has his day in the sun, new guy comes ruining it, etc.

It probably wasn’t the best episode, but then again it’s hard to be the best Simpsons episode, now isn’t it?

13 years ago

THAT is Jeffrey Loria?

Funny how we make up images of people. I feel the same way like when I saw a photo of NASCAR’s James Finch. Way off.

Among educated internet people, both sabermetric and old school, the Marlins always seem trendy, underrated and likeable.

Michael Caragliano
13 years ago

The Mets are more like Gil the inept salesman. Always plugging away, only to fall well short selling the goods, and then masking their self-pity by muttering about how they were so close this time, when you really knew they never had a shot and were in way over their heads. Yet we watch anyway. (The Simpsons, that is. The Mets, I had to stop watching in June.) Besides, only The Simpsons could make the “Darryl Darryl” chant seem fresh and funny again.

13 years ago

I KNEW my Jays would be Frank Grimes.

The Yankees could also be Nelson. Wins by sheer size and wholly obnoxious in victory. Ha-ha!

Also, spot on with Lisa as the Braves. You know you should like her but you can’t help rolling your eyes whenever she shows up. Springfield’s answer to a question nobody asked!

Now… which character best represents the sabermetric community? Once again I vote Lisa: usually right, a little snarky, and can be thin-skinned and defensive when things don’t go her way. Take that, Lisa’s beliefs!

Jason B
13 years ago

Chris –

Sooooo true; how can you pick just one?  And I had forgotten some of the memorable quips in the GHWB episode and was thinking more of the overall premise.

The SABR community may be Martin Prince – very geeky, pretty smug in their (our?) own smarts, rarely a central focus but has some nice moments on the periphery.  (That description and character could apply to the A’s and Billy Beane also, I guess?)

13 years ago

Sabermetricians = Comic Book Guy of course

Dayton Moore
13 years ago

I bent my Wookiee.

13 years ago

Good list and pretty much nailed each team with the character.Also,if you’re interested,the “Crazy Cat Lady’s” (Orioles) name is Eleanor Abernathy.

Steve D.
13 years ago

OK, the Orioles line made me laugh, but the Angelos comments are like three years too late.  What’s the last crazy thing he did?

I prefer Hans Moleman.  He’s a train wreck, but if he ever got his act together… well, it won’t matter, he’ll still be Hans Moleman.  “I was saying Boo-urns…”

13 years ago

This could be the stupidest fucking thing I have ever seen. Come on don’t you have better things to do with your life. This is baseball, how can you compare the teams to a cartoon show. You’re an idiot for writing this.
That is all I have to say thanks.

13 years ago

Hey bigjames, perhaps you should try acquiring something called a “sense of humor” you fucking troll.

Oh, and Gil as the Mets is spot on.

Chris J.
13 years ago

“This could be the stupidest fucking thing I have ever seen.”

Stick around – I’ll have a new article up next week.

Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Griffin
13 years ago

The Orioles: Old Gil
The Pirates: Hans Moleman