Hall of Fame Plaques Reflect the Style at the Time

Wade Boggs’ is the first to mention on-base percentage. Lou Boudreau’s describes him as a “player-pilot,” a term that’s been out of use for more than half a century. Jackie Robinson’s initially made no mention of him breaking the color barrier. Phil Rizzuto’s reads almost like a defense for inclusion, noting he had a “solid .273 batting average” and (this seems like an odd thing to highlight) “peaked with a .439 slugging percentage” one season. The first line of Babe Ruth’s is “Greatest drawing card in history of baseball.”

We’re talking, of course, about Hall of Fame plaques, which are ripe with charming, informative and idiosyncratic text, often reflective of the era in which they were written.

Ruth? He “gathered 714 home runs.” Jack Beckley? He “made 2930 hits.” Cool Papa Bell? “Hit over .300 regularly, topping .400 on occasion.” Love that – “on occasion,” as if it were the decision to wear a tuxedo.

“The plaques illustrate the way that we, the baseball fans and the baseball industry, have changed our mindset and the way we talk about the game,” said Jon Shestakofsky, vice president of communications and education for the National Baseball Hall of Fame. “Not only have things changed grammatically and linguistically over time, which was pretty funny to see. But also the types of information that are going up on plaques, like a lot more stats.”

The writing of the text on the 314 plaques now hanging in Cooperstown has always been a collaborative effort between Hall historians and the communications department, traditionally with no input from inductees.

“The way we think about it is, if we ever tried to run it by players, it would never get done,” said Shestakofsky, laughing.

Exploring the gallery of plaques is like leafing through old copies of The Sporting News, where many of the terms and descriptions seem quaintly dated – even instructional. Do you know what constitutes a perfect game? If not, you can read the last line of Cy Young’s plaque: “Pitched perfect game May 5, 1904, no opposing batsman reaching first base.”

The first five members of the Hall of Fame – Ruth, Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner, Christy Mathewson and Walter Johnson – were elected in 1936. Their plaques topped out at around 30 words. If someone asked you to summarize the career of Babe Ruth in so few words, how would you do it? With stats? A description of his stature in the game? A mixture of both? Ruth’s full plaque actually reads:

Greatest drawing card in history of baseball. Holder of many home run and other batting records. Gathered 714 home runs in addition to fifteen in World Series.”

That’s it, 27 words over three lines — for the greatest player in baseball history. With the help of laser printing and a more concise font, more recent plaques can have around 90 words. If you were charged with writing (or re-writing) Ruth’s plaque, maybe you would mention his pitching excellence, too. Or that he long held the record for consecutive scoreless innings in the World Series. Nevertheless, the plaques were never meant to be exhaustive descriptions of a baseball figure’s career, any more than a tombstone contains the full impact of a person’s life.

“You look at Babe Ruth’s plaque, there’s a short snippet and it doesn’t really have numbers on it,” Shestakofsky said. “It more describes his impact on the game. And then you look at a guy who went in a few years ago, let’s say Pedro Martinez. It’s much heavier on text, many more words and lines. By comparison that might look like a big difference, but you’re still talking about 85 to 90 words to sum up an inductee’s entire career and impact on baseball. It’s not an easy task by any means. We try to emphasize the Hall of Famer’s unique place in the game and their stamp on history and hopefully offer something distinctive that stands out a little bit.”

In addition to the relative paucity of stats on Ruth’s plaque, it reads, “Gathered 714 home runs.” No one today would say that a hitter “gathered” home runs or hits. But such era-respective terms pop up regularly on plaques throughout the years.

Walter Johnson’s plaque begins, “Conceded to be fastest ball pitcher in history of game.” Ball pitcher? Were there other types of pitchers in those days? Of course not, but that’s how they were widely described.

It’s written of Connie Mack, who was inducted in 1937: “Received the Bok Award in Philadelphia in 1929.” What’s the Bok Award? Got me, but it was apparently a big enough thing in its day to merit mention on his Hall of Fame plaque.

(Note: Okay, I looked it up. The Bok Award is more commonly known as The Philadelphia Award and is given annually to a figure in that city whose “service to others tends to make lives happy and communities prosperous.” Also, Connie Mack’s name before he shortened it was Cornelius McGillicuddy. Not surprisingly, his full name does not appear on his plaque.)

In 1938, Grover Cleveland Alexander was elected as a member of the Hall’s third class of inductees. His might have the best text of any plaque, the last line reading, “Won 1926 World Championship for Cardinals by striking out Lazzeri with bases full in final crisis at Yankee Stadium.” Beyond the type of flowery language that might have made Grantland Rice proud, it’s notable that Tony Lazzeri was on a Hall plaque by last name only in 1938 — 53 years before he himself was inducted in 1991.

Part of Lou Gehrig’s 1939 plaque reads, “Holder of more than a score of major and American league records,” back when everyday people knew the score, i.e., that the word meant 20.

“I think about it the same I do in seeing old baseball headlines in the pre-World War II era,” Shestakofsky said. “It was just a different world and a different way of writing and consuming the drama of the game. I really enjoy reading those older plaques and kind of reveling in the alternate language. It’s a lot of fun and it really just reflects a different way of connecting with the game.”

Slugging percentage is routinely mentioned on plaques throughout the years, while statistics such as on-base percentage (which weren’t duly appreciated for many years) are notably absent. Ted Williams has the highest on-base percentage in history (.482), but his 1966 plaque doesn’t mention it. In fact, the first plaque to cite on-base percentage was Wade Boggs’ in 2005.

Among the most charming aspects of Hall of Fame plaques are the inclusion of tidbits that might seem extraneous (or even insulting) given the dearth of available space. The first line of Ernie Lombardi’s is a back-handed compliment: “Hit .306 over 17 seasons despite slowness afoot.” The last line of Travis Jackson’s plaque reads, “Drove in more than 90 runs three times, reaching 101 on .268 average in 1934.” I’m not sure Jackson (a .291 career hitter elected in 1982) would have elected for the last stat on his Hall of Fame plaque to note a .268 batting average.

It’s not just words but also punctuation that has changed. For Frank Robinson, the text partly reads, “Set records for hitting homers in 32 different parks and with pair of grand-slammers in successive innings in 1970.” Not only is the term “grand slammers” no longer in common use, but “grand slam” is no longer hyphenated. But many words that are now written as two separate words were commonly hyphenated. “Home-run” is hyphenated in describing the accomplishments on Home Run Baker’s plaque (though, strangely, his nickname is not), and “Grand-slam” is hyphenated on Ernie Banks’ plaque, whereas no one would hyphenate either of those words today.

Banks, for his part, is recognized for once leading the league in slugging percentage, which might seem like a trifle to mention when you only have so many words with which to highlight a Hall of Fame career. Meanwhile, Barry Larkin’s plaque makes no mention of him winning the 1995 National League MVP, even though at the time he was the first NL shortstop to nab that honor in more than 30 years.

Many plaques mention a player’s nickname, including “The Say Hey Kid” for Willie Mays and “Country” for Enos Slaughter. Some seem superfluous, i.e., “Mike” for Michael Joseph Piazza — particularly when you see that Michael Jack Schmidt didn’t receive the same treatment. Meanwhile, Raymond Brown’s plaque notes that his nickname was, wait for it, Ray; Anthony Gwynn was “Tony”; and Thomas Michael Glavine’s was “Tom.”

Some of the nicknames were new on me, including “Beauty” for Dave Bancroft. By the way, with all due respect to Tim Raines, there’s already a “Rock” in Cooperstown. That was Earl Averill’s nickname, and it says so on his plaque.

It’s educational to learn that Roberto Alomar’s real last name is Velasquez. Bert Blyleven’s plaque lists his full birth name: Rik Aalbert Blyleven. Oddly, the plaque for former Negro League owner Effa Manley, who was inducted in 2006, does not mention that she was the first woman elected to the Hall of Fame.

Several plaques have been amended over the years to account for corrections to stats and dates played. Jackie Robinson’s text was given a wholesale rewriting; initially when he was elected in 1962, he didn’t want the focus to be on him breaking the color barrier, so the text cited only his on-field play. It was later changed and now ends with the line, “Displayed tremendous courage and poise in 1947 when he integrated the modern major leagues in the face of intense adversity.”

“Clearly over time, it was decided that based on his place in history, outside of what happened on the playing field, it deserved to be mentioned, so that plaque was updated to reflect his unique place in the game,” Shestakofsky said.

That doesn’t overstate things in the least. The same cannot be said about other Hall of Fame plaques, where hyperbole runs rampant. Rickey Henderson’s opens with “Faster than a speeding bullet.” George Brett’s reads in part, “A clutch hitter whose profound respect for the game led to universal reverence.”

(Why am I picturing him tearing out of the dugout in the Pine Tar Game?)

The purple prose that marked Grover Cleveland Alexander’s plaque has not disappeared from plaques over the years. Glavine’s opens with “Durable, dominant and deceptive starting pitcher,” and Greg Maddux’s with “One of the game’s most consistent, composed and celebrated starting pitchers.”

The text of plaques continues to evolve, but an appreciation for the written word continues to shine through in honoring the national pastime and the players and figures central to its history. Inductees don’t see what’s written on their plaques until the monuments are unveiled during induction ceremonies.

“I think the players enjoy seeing for the first time what’s on their plaques,” Shestakofsky said.. “They get a real thrill out of it.”