Recasting the Red Sox-Yankee rivalry

Imagine that for the past century, both the Yankees and Red Sox had been operating their own youth academies, European-soccer style. Except, unlike Manchester United or Real Madrid, which supplement home-grown talent with foreign imports, both the Bombers and Sox could draw only from a talent pool comprised of their respective fan bases. In this scenario, which team would have had greater success?

Looking beyond the performance of the teams and at the people who support them adds a new dimension to a rivalry that has lost its edge. The turning point was the 2004 ALCS, when Boston overcame a 3-0 deficit to defeat New York en route to its first World Series victory in 85 years.

No longer a lovable band of underachievers, the Red Sox today are viewed less as a foil to the Yankees than as a successful imitator. While no team can match the Yankees’ spending, the Red Sox spend lavishly themselves and have ranked second to the Bombers in salary for seven of the last ten years. The Yankees are still US Steel, but the Red Sox are Apple.

What the feud lacks is any local grounding. Boston versus New York has always been as much about two adjacent regions as the teams themselves. Determining which region has nurtured better players is at least as good an indicator of long-term success as counting the number of championships delivered by casts of ringers to their Midwestern owners. We’ve watched Red Sox play the Yankees countless times; but we’ve never seen happens when New England takes on New York.

Setting the rules

The northeast has produced its share of transcendent baseball players, many of whom never once donned Yankee pinstripes or red stockings. Yet, compiling a 25-man roster of each region’s most deserving players is a more difficult task than it might seem. The thorniest issue involves establishing a border. Over the years, a few sportswriters have taken a stab at marking where Red Sox Nation and Yankeeland meet.

I’ve decided to adhere to this New York Times article and linked map, which traces a diagonal line across Connecticut, and follow the Vermont-New York border north to Canada. The Times map doesn’t chart the southern reaches of the Yankee’s Jersey fan base, but most people agree that the state can be bisected at Trenton, with the eight counties south of the capital in Philadelphia’s orbit.

More controversially, and to the great detriment of the New York roster, I’ve eliminated all of geographical Long Island, which includes Suffolk and Nassau counties, as well as Brooklyn and Queens. Not only did it seem egregious to include a territory that leaned first to the Dodgers and then to the Mets, but excising this populous chunk of the state helps compensate for New England’s demographic disadvantage.

The downside is that New Yorkers Phil Rizzuto, Whitey Ford, Sandy Koufax and Joe Torre, to name just a few, will all have to watch from the stands, as will another name familiar to the rivalry, Bridgehampton’s Carl Yastrzemski.

Red Sox Nation is easier to define. Its members states are Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine, Rhode Island and central and northern Connecticut. Fixing the Nation’s borders along state lines will likely rankle many in upstate New York, which is a hotly contested area, particularly in the east. Moreover, some Connecticut-bred players are from towns located very close or even directly on the Times’ border.

This geographical inconvenience leads to my first caveat: Any player from a town or city that legitimately can be claimed by either side is ineligible. The best player who falls in this category is Jeff Bagwell, who grew up in Killingsworth, Connecticut and attended high school in Middletown, which straddles the Connecticut River, the Rio Grande of the rivalry.

Being born in Red Sox or Yankee country doesn’t automatically qualify a player for consideration. A player must have spent the bulk of his formative baseball playing years in the New England or the New York area.

Sorry, Yankee fans, but Alex Rodriguez and Edgar Martinez, both of whom left New York City before they were old enough to pick up a bat, are out. On the other hand, Rod Carew and Manny Ramirez, two Latin American-born alums of George Washington High School in Manhattan, can suit up.

Players from the 19th century are not eligible. Each region has produced its share of Hall of Famers from that era, but, in an exercise about the fan base of the Yankee-Red Sox rivalry, it would seem odd if either roster included players who predated it.

Those players who split their playing career across two centuries can play, provided that the spent of majority of it in the 20th. This is good news for New England, which is able to call on the great Napoleon Lajoie, who began his career in 1896.

The rosters

Because of its drastic demographic advantage, one would expect the Yankee side to win handily. Even without counting Long Island and the densely packed Queens and Brooklyn, New York state holds slightly more people—12.9 million—than all of Red Sox Nation.

When you factor in southern Connecticut and north and central New Jersey, its population edge grows by another eight million. Though not quite as stark in earlier decades, this disparity has existed throughout the 20th century.

A Hardball Times Update
Goodbye for now.

Reviewing each side’s all-time roster, however, it becomes clear that the two teams are not that far apart. Starting with the infield, both teams boast a dazzling collection of talent, with seven Hall of Famers between them.

New York

Pos  Player             Hometown        Years active     HOF?   Career WAR
C    John Romano        Hoboken, NJ       1958-1967       N           22.7
1B   Lou Gehrig         New York, NY      1930-1947       Y          118.4
2B   Eddie Collins      Tarrytown, NY     1906-1930       Y          126.7
SS   Johnny Logan       Endicott, NY      1951-1963       N           29.6
3B   Frankie Frisch     Bronx, NY         1919-1937       Y           74.8

New England

Pos  Player             Hometown            Years active     HOF?   Career WAR
C    Mickey Cochrane    Charlestown, NH       1969-1993       Y           51.2
1B   Stuffy McInnis     Gloucester, MA        1909-1927       N           29.8
2B   Nap Lajoie         Woonsocket, RI        1896-1916       Y          104.2
SS   Rabbit Maranville  Springfield, MA       1912-1935       Y           38.2
3B   Pie Traynor        Somerville, MA        1920-1937       Y           37.1

Powered by Eddie Collins and Lou Gehrig, each of whom was arguably the best ever at his position, the New York infield is stronger. Still, Red Sox Nation at least proves that it belongs on the field, with better players at catcher and shortstop in Mickey Cochrane and Rabbit Maranville. However, any hope for competitiveness, at least offensively, withers once you consider the team’s respective outfields.

New York

Pos  Player          Hometown        Years active     HOF?   Career WAR
OF   Manny Ramirez   New York, NY      1993-2011       N*          66.8
OF   Rocky Colavito  Bronx, NY         1955-1968       N           46.4
OF   Joe Medwick     Carteret, NJ      1932-1948       Y           55.8

New England

Pos  Player             Hometown     Years active     HOF?   Career WAR
OF   Tony Conigliaro    Boston, MA     1964-1975       N            8.7
OF   Shano Collins      Boston, MA     1910-1925       N            8.9
OF   Jimmy Barrett      Athol, MA      1899-1908       N           20.7

The paucity of decent outfielders from New England presents this exercise’s first true outlier. How can a region that has generated so many transcendent ballplayers have nurtured so few decent outfielders?

Plain bad luck might be one answer. It certainly played a role in derailing the career of Tony Conigliaro, whose face was shattered by a Jack Hamilton fastball. Rhode Island-bred Rocco Baldelli is another outfielder with great promise from New England whose career was stopped in its tracks due to injury.

The New York outfield is stellar across the board and includes former Yankee-slayer Manny Ramirez. Scores of other outfielders from the region who wouldn’t stand a chance at making the roster would start for New England, from former All-Stars like B.J. Surhoff to the light-hitting Dan Pasqua.

The battle between the teams’ respective benches, which include the standard mix of position players, again favors New York, though both teams have multiple Hall of Famers to call on to pinch-hit in a big spot.

New York

Pos     Player            Hometown           Years active     HOF?   Career WAR
1B      Hank Greenberg    Bronx, NY            1930-1947       Y           56.8
1B/2B   Rod Carew         New York, NY         1967-1985       Y           79.1
C       Frankie Hayes     Pennington, NJ       1933-1947       N           14.2
3B      Heine Groh        Rochester, NY        1912-1927       N           46.4
OF      Devon White       New York, NY         1985-2001       N           41.3
OF      Larry Doby        Paterson, NJ         1947-1959       Y           47.4
OF      Ken Singleton     Mount Vernon, NY     1970-1984       N           40.6

New England

Pos     Player            Hometown           Years active     HOF?   Career WAR
C       Carlton Fisk      Charlestown, NH      1969-1993       Y           67.3
3B      Larry Gardner     Enosburg Falls, VT   1908-1924       N           43.0
2B      Davey Lopes       Providence, RI       1972-1987       N           39.3
SS      Dick McAuliffe    Farmington, CT       1960-1975       N           35.1
3B/1B   Richie Hebner     Norwood, MA          1968-1985       N           35.9
OF      Rocco Baldelli    Woonsocket, RI       2003-2010       N            6.5
OF      Johnny Barrett    Lowell, MA           1942-1946       N            7.0

Boston’s lack of outfielders is made even more apparent by the inclusion on the bench of Baldelli and Johnny Barrett, two players with undistinguished careers. You can’t imagine either player stealing at-bats from Carlton Fisk or Larry Gardner, the only player from Vermont to crack the roster.

Led by Hall of Famers Hank Greenberg and Rod Carew, New York’s bench has virtually no weak spot. Without a need for another bat, the speedy Devon White, one of the games’ premier fielders in his day, makes more sense as the 25th man than a superior hitter like Andy Van Slyke (New Hartford, NY), Bobby Thomson (Staten Island, NY) or Mo Vaughn (Norwalk, CT).

While New York has the decisive edge on offense, the pitching matchup is more competitive. To maintain a semblance of verisimilitude, I’ve given each roster two “pure” relievers, confident that at least a few of the starters listed would be able to make a transition to relief.

New York

Pos   Player            Hometown           Years active     HOF?   Career WAR
SP    Warren Spahn      Buffalo, NY          1942-1965       Y           93.4
SP    Don Newcombe      Madison, NJ          1949-1960       N           29.7
SP    Sal Maglie        Niagara Falls, NY    1945-1958       N           32.6
SP    Eddie Lopat       New York, NY         1944-1955       N           31.9
SP    Johnny Antonelli  Rochester, NY        1948-1961       N           32.0
SP    Al Leiter         Toms River, NJ       1987-2005       N           38.8
SP    John Candelaria   New York, NY         1975-1993       N           37.8
SP    Bill Hands        Rutherford, NJ       1965-1975       N           31.8
RP    Joe Nathan        Pine Bush, NY      1999-present      N*          21.8
RP    Bob Stanley       Kearney, NJ          1977-1989       N           21.5

New England

Pos   Player              Hometown           Years active     HOF?   Career WAR
SP    Tom Glavine         Bellerica, MA        1987-2008       N*          67.0
SP    Wilbur Wood         Belmont, MA          1961-1978       N           45.0
SP    Jack Chesbro        North Adams,MA       1899-1909       Y           33.2
SP    Wild Bill Donovan   Lawrence, MA         1898-1918       N           34.8
SP    Chris Carpenter     Raymond, NH        1997-present       N*          30.7
SP    Vic Raschi          Springfield, MA      1946-1955       N           21.4
SP    Dick Donovan        Boston, MA           1950-1965       N           20.1
SP    Mike Flanagan       Manchester, NY       1975-1992       N           23.9
RP    Jeff Reardon        Dalton, MA           1979-1994       N           20.3
RP    Steve Bedrosian     Methuen, MA          1981-1995       N           16.4

One of games’ all-time greats, Buffalo’s Warren Spahn is the best pitcher in the contest. After the Buffalo-bred southpaw, the dropoff is quite steep; not a single one of Spahn’s New York rotation mates accrued even half of his career win shares.

On the other hand, the New England staff is far more balanced. While Tom Glavine likely would struggle to match Spahn in the first game of a hypothetical seven-game series, Wilbur Wood, Jack Chesbro and Wild Bill Donovan would give New England a fair shot in the next three.

Before he moved to New Jersey, reliever Bob Stanley was born in Red Sox Nation, where his name lives on in ignominy for his role in Boston’s collapse in the 1986 World Series. What’s forgotten is that he actually put together a decent career.

Contemporaries Steve Bedrosian and Jeff Reardon form a stellar back-end of the bullpen for New England, though one imagines that when his career is over, New Hampshire native Brian Wilson will be able to make a compelling case for a spot.

In a game with Hall of Fame talent—and egos to match—having a manager with steely nerves is paramount. Without the benefit of an objective metric, it’s more difficult to declare an edge in the managerial category, and New York and New England each can lay a claim to raising the game’s best-ever manager.

New York

Manager        Hometown           Years active   HOF?
John McGraw    Truxton, NY    1899-1932     Y


Manager        Hometown                  Years active       HOF?
Connie Mack    East Brookfield, MA   1894-1894, 1901-1950    Y

Massachusetts native Connie Mack, who managed more games than anyone else in baseball history, is an easy choice for New England. Joe Torre would be the sentimental pick for New York, but his Brooklyn upbringing eliminates him from consideration. John McGraw is hardly a slouch, however, and, one could easily see him forging a good relationship with the mercurial Ramirez, just as Torre did in Los Angeles.

Final Thoughts

While New England’s pitching would make it a close content, it is safe to say that the fan base of the New York Yankees would field a better overall team. This does not mean, however, that New York is more fertile soil for talent. On a per capita basis, New England’s ability to breed baseball players is at least equal to that of New York. And in this way, the contest reflects real life. The Red Sox do more with less, but the Yankees are still the Yankees.

References & Resources
Career WAR (Wins Above Replacement) values are from Baseball Reference.

newest oldest most voted
Bob Rittner
Bob Rittner

Is Wally Schang eligible to play for the Yankees? Both BB-Ref and Fangraphs have his career WAR over 43. I think he was born and raised near Buffalo, NY and played semi-pro ball in the area while in high school.


Ok, I had to do this for Missouri (home state) to see how it compared: Pitching, while not having anyone as good as Spahn, is actually deeper.  SP:  Carl Hubbell 64.4, David Cone 57.5, Mark Buehrle 46.6, Steve Rogers 45.8, Mel Stottlemyre 37.9, Al Orth 33.3, Curt Davis 33.2, Jerry Reuss 33.1…those are all the starters.  Pen is Murry Dickson 38.9, Tom Henke 23.1, and a special spot for Smokey Joe Wood as the super utility player.  He can start, relieve, or play the OF:  26.2 WAR as a P, 9.3 as an OF.  This list also doesn’t include some… Read more »


The everyday lineup isn’t as strong. C:  Yogi Berra 61.9 1B:  Ryan Howard 23.1, or Jake Beckley at 61.5 (played mainly pre – 1900 2B:  Jimmy Williams 32.4 SS:  Charlie Hollocher 22.6 3B:  Kenny Boyer 58.4 OF:  Zach Wheat 57.8 OF:  Pete Reiser 24.1 OF:  Bake McBride 21.2 I’m already counting Smokey Joe Wood as the super utility.  The rest of the bench: OF:  Bernard Gilkey 21.4 OF/SS:  George Van Haltren 45.1 – I’m cheating here because he mostly played prior to 1900 2B:  Ron Hunt 30 1B:  Jake Beckley 61.5 C:  Elston Howard 28.2 OF/1B:  Norm Siebern 22.5 Manager: … Read more »


Aaron, the show me state does indeed put forward a fairly strong team. I’d be curious how other states/regions stack up. My guess is that the all-California team would be the most formidable, and not just because of its immense population advantage.

Bob, well done spotting the omission of Schang. According to his SABR bio, Schang grew up near Buffalo, and thus would be eligible.

David P Stokes
David P Stokes

What the heck—the all-born in WV team: C:  Andy Seminick 20.7 N 1B:  John Kruk 26.1 N 2B:  Bill Mazeroski 26.9 Y SS:  Jack Glasscock 58.7 N 3B:  George Brett 85.O Y OF:  Jesse Burkett 68.0 Y OF:  Greasy Neale 6.0 N OF:  Farmer Weaver 1.8 N Bench: C:  Steve Yeager 15.4 N IF:  Toby Harrah 47.1 N C/1B/OF: John Wockenfoss 5.8 N IF:  Gene Freese:  7.7 N 1B/OF:  Del Gainer 7.8 N Starters: Wilbur Cooper:  43.7 N Lew Burdette:  25.3 N Rick Reed:  17.8 N Chuck Stubbs:  17.1 N Win Mercer:  14.1 N Bullpen:  Max Butcher:  13.7 N Jack… Read more »


Thanks for the fun post!

However, I believe it would be more correct to say the Red Sox overcame an 0-3 deficit (not 3-0). And it was 86 years, not 85, since the 1918 title.

Señor Spielbergo
Señor Spielbergo

If the Canadian province of New Brunswick is considered Red Sox Nation (which it arguably is), Matt Stairs (career WAR: 13.5) could come off the bench as a 1B/corner OF.

Arrie bachrach
Arrie bachrach

Enjoyable and thought provoking article!  Enjoyed the offerings in response, as well.