Staff rankings: Third base
We finish up the infield with the top 25 men at the hot corner. The staffers who ranked are Josh Shepardson, Ben Pritchett, Brad Johnson and yours truly. We used FantasyPros.com to create our composite rankings, and if you follow the link provided in our rankings, you can see how ours compared with a slew of other experts’.
Assume a 12-team, mixed league with standard 5×5 settings. Click on the links with our names to get to our Twitter accounts, where we’ll happily answer your baseball and fantasy questions year-round.
| 2012 Third basemen rankings | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Player name | Nick Fleder |
Ben Prichett |
Josh Shepardson |
Brad Johnson |
THT Composite |
FantasyPros Expert Consensus |
| Jose Bautista | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | compare |
| Evan Longoria | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | compare |
| Adrian Beltre | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | compare |
| Ryan Zimmerman | 6 | 5 | 5 | 3 | 4 | compare |
| David Wright | 4 | 3 | 6 | 7 | 5 | compare |
| Brett Lawrie | 5 | 6 | 4 | 8 | 6 | compare |
| Pablo Sandoval | 7 | 10 | 7 | 5 | 7 | compare |
| Alex Rodriguez | 8 | 8 | 8 | 6 | 8 | compare |
| Michael Young | 9 | 7 | 11 | 10 | 9 | compare |
| Kevin Youkilis | 11 | 9 | 10 | 9 | 10 | compare |
| Aramis Ramirez | 10 | 11 | 9 | 12 | 11 | compare |
| Mark Reynolds | 12 | 12 | 12 | 11 | 12 | compare |
| Mike Moustakas | 13 | 14 | 14 | 13 | 13 | compare |
| David Freese | 14 | 13 | 13 | 15 | 14 | compare |
| Edwin Encarnacion | 16 | 17 | 15 | 14 | 15 | compare |
| Emilio Bonifacio | 15 | 15 | 17 | 19 | 16 | compare |
| Chase Headley | 19 | 20 | 16 | 16 | 17 | compare |
| Martin Prado | 17 | 16 | 18 | 20 | 18 | compare |
| Ryan Roberts | 18 | 18 | 20 | 17 | 19 | compare |
| Chipper Jones | 20 | 21 | 19 | 21 | 20 | compare |
| Lonnie Chisenhall | 21 | 19 | 21 | – | 21 | compare |
| Daniel Murphy | – | 22 | 25 | 22 | 22 | compare |
| Casey McGehee | – | 33 | – | 18 | 23 | compare |
| Pedro Alvarez | 24 | – | 22 | – | 24 | compare |
| Danny Valencia | 25 | 32 | 23 | 24 | 25 | compare |
Fantasy Baseball Rankings powered by FantasyPros, the leading aggregator of expert fantasy advice.
Next Monday… Outfield
Hanley’s going to be used as a SS 90% of the time. And I was considering McGehee as their 1B. He may platoon with Jones of course, but if he starts on the right foot he could have a full time job quickly between 1b and 3b.
Yeah, but is someone really going to put Hanley at third? Unless you also have Reyes, Tulo or Castro; you would probably better off keeping him as your SS and picking Ramirez or Reynolds as your 3b.
I could see several scenarios where Hanley ends a draft as your third baseman especially if the 3B position fills fast in leagues without a MI position. Hanley could be drafted as a shortstop but wind up as a third baseman if I’m having to draft Stephen Drew over the likes of Chase Headley. I’d much rather have Drew at SS and Hanley at 3B than Hanley at SS and Headley at 3B.
In agreement with Brad, that may be a 10 percent occurrence.
I think you’ll also find that over the course of the season, the “crap” at third base is going to be a lot better than the “crap” at SS. So once you start making waiver moves, you might end up with an Ian Stewart taking over at third base and pushing Hanley back to SS.
Now where is the 2011 NL’s Gold Glove winner in all of this????? I think his name was Placido Polanco.
I’m surprised that no one is including Miguel Cabrera in these rankings with his return to 3b. Succeed or fail defensively, he’ll play enough to get rated in most fantasy leagues, and I would expect top the list.
(Maybe this piece was put together before the Fielder signing.)
I started considering Polanco around #15 bu never had the heart to put him down.
I’m a Phillies fan, so I feel qualified to speak to Polanco’s prospects. He’s battled a ton of injury over the last two seasons. He’s a warrior who can play through serious hurts, but it damages his fantasy numbers. His upside is a high batting average with no power, no steals, and at best average R/RBI. Based on the other guys we have on that list, I can’t imagine ranking that upside above them…especially since the last two years have indicated that the downside is far more likely.
@Mike- As for me, I had Polanco at my 25. He didn’t make the list because no one else ranked him.
Jim G- Cabrera is not ranked because he is not yet Yahoo eligible at third. Same thing can be said for Hanley. We based these rankings on Yahoo eligibility. As you’ll see in our overall rankings, the possible future position eligibility will be calculated in there.
You’ll notice that right away on my top 250 list. I have Pujols as the top 1B yet Cabrera tops the big board on the expectation that he’ll gain 3b eligibility.
I tried not to consider position eligibility in my position lists. I know some of my colleagues did, perhaps we should have discussed that ahead of time…
Assuming positional eligibility, I’d re-rank with Cabrera and Hanley:
Rank Player Name Team
1 Miguel Cabrera* DET
2 Jose Bautista TOR
3 Hanley Ramirez MIA
4 Evan Longoria TBR
5 David Wright NYM
6 Adrian Beltre TEX
7 Ryan Zimmerman WAS
8 Alex Rodriguez NYY
9 Pablo Sandoval SFG
10 Brett Lawrie TOR
11 Michael Young TEX
12 Kevin Youkilis BOS
13 Aramis Ramirez MIL
14 Mark Reynolds BAL
15 Martin Prado ATL
16 Edwin Encarnacion TOR
17 Mike Moustakas KCR
18 Ian Stewart CHC
19 David Freese STL
20 Emilio Bonifacio MIA
21 Chipper Jones ATL
22 Lonnie Chisenhall CLE
I think people are a little too down on Hanley, who is a perennial .290+/15-20/30 guy on a much improved roster. Longoria will likely hit .280/30/10 and Wright .280+/20-25/15-20. I think Hanley is in the same tier as those two guys but with better overall upside. I would not be offended if someone made me put Longo over hanley though
In fact, if I had to break down the above list into “tiers” it would look like this (a break is a tier)
Rank Player Name Team
1 Miguel Cabrera* DET
2 Jose Bautista TOR
3 Hanley Ramirez* MIA
4 Evan Longoria TBR
5 David Wright NYM
6 Adrian Beltre TEX
7 Ryan Zimmerman WAS
8 Alex Rodriguez NYY
9 Pablo Sandoval SFG
10 Brett Lawrie TOR
11 Michael Young TEX
12 Kevin Youkilis BOS
13 Aramis Ramirez MIL
14 Mark Reynolds BAL
15 Martin Prado ATL
16 Edwin Encarnacion TOR
17 Mike Moustakas KCR
18 Ian Stewart CHC
19 David Freese STL
20 Emilio Bonifacio MIA
21 Chipper Jones ATL
22 Lonnie Chisenhall CLE
My tentative Top 20:
1. Jose Bautista
2. Evan Longoria
3. David Wright
4. Adrian Beltre
5. Ryan Zimmerman
6. Pablo Sandoval
7. Brett Lawrie
8. Alex Rodriguez
9. Aramis Ramirez
10. Kevin Youkilis
11. Michael Young
12. Mark Reynolds
13. David Freese
14. Mike Moustakas
15. Chase Headley
16. Edwin Encarnacion
17. Emilio Bonifacio
18. Martin Prado
19. Ryan Roberts
20. Pedro Alvarez
I actually think 3B looks a bit better deeper this year than the last couple years, but there’s a lot more risk. Gone are the days when you could really feel secure in drafting a Top 3B and not worry about the position for the whole year.
A few notes:
-I’m willing to give Wright one more shot at 25-25 with a reasonable AVG thanks to the new dimensions at CitiField.
-I flipped Wright and Beltre a number of times. They’re pretty interchangeable in value. Wright has the SB which gives him more upside and a different kind of floor, but no matter how weird it feels to say it, Beltre is “safer”.
-I’m very bipolar on Lawrie. In one sense, I love his upside and feel his speed helps give him a high floor for a young player. However, ultimately, I’ve been burned too many times by investing heavily in young players because I focused too much on their recent performance and upsides (Read: Jason Heyward). If I’m willing to pay $25 for Wright, I don’t want to pay more than $20 for Lawrie, even if a part of me feels more comfortable with the latter. I’d rather risk someone else getting a slight bargain on him than risk reaching for him too early myself.
-Young and Youkilis can be flipped—Youk offers more potential reward in HR but carries more risk while Young is a nice safe play at 3B.
-Ramirez can be infuriating to own at times, but I like him as a safer version of Youk if you can be patient with him through the bad times, so he gets a bump.
-Headley has some sneaky upside if the Padres decide to move him, though that may not happen until the second half, if at all.
-I’d rather take a chance on Alvarez finding a way to make more frequent contact than conceding the spot to an essentially replacement-level player like Murphy or Valencia.
-Chipper Jones could essentially be 20b, but I wanted to point out that I still have a sliver of hope for Alvarez.
I. too, would consider Alvarez a good flier. I’d rather play the lottery on him than draft somebody like Chipper or Polanco, who has pretty much established bench-level fantasy value.
I’d even take a shot on McGehee, depending on what news comes from Pirates camp. He could platoon at 1B with Jones, and if Alvarez tanks again, that would be another route to playing time. If last year was mostly an outlier, you could very conceivably wind up with solid starting CI level value from him. …But, the path to full time ABs has to be become largely unobstructed.
At first glance, I think Sandoval is too low. I have him 5th, ahead of Zimmerman and Lawrie
I also wouldn’t have McGehee on the list at all, I think that would have Brent Morel, Ian Stewart or Scott Sizemore getting some consideration for the last couple of spots on the list as well.
I had Sandoval third until about the weight (re)gain.
Hopping in early. My tentative top 20:
Rank Player Name Team
1 Jose Bautista TOR
2 Evan Longoria TBR
3 David Wright NYM
4 Adrian Beltre TEX
5 Ryan Zimmerman WAS
6 Alex Rodriguez NYY
7 Pablo Sandoval SFG
8 Brett Lawrie TOR
9 Michael Young TEX
10 Kevin Youkilis BOS
11 Aramis Ramirez MIL
12 Mark Reynolds BAL
13 Martin Prado ATL
14 Edwin Encarnacion TOR
15 Mike Moustakas KCR
16 Ian Stewart CHC
17 David Freese STL
18 Emilio Bonifacio MIA
19 Chipper Jones ATL
20 Lonnie Chisenhall CLE
I had the Panda sixth, Brad. For the reason I liked him last year, it seems I will have the opposite feeling since he’s back hitting the buffets.
And Dave, I had Morel in my top 25 and Sizemore wasn’t far away if memory serves me correctly.
A-Rod doesn’t even make my top ten. After name recognition, I see a chronically injured (legs and hips, including surgery) 36 yo who has basically admitted his best numbers were inflated by steroid use, which may also be playing a part in his body’s breakdown now. His slugging% is in a 5-year decline, the SB’s are gone… you are paying for brand name.
Probably true. I’m gambling a little on the Orthokine treatment helping him measurably.
If healthy, a 90/25/110/5/.270 projected line probably isn’t overly bullish. That compares favorably to the 75/20/80/15/.285 line I have pegged out for Wright.
Just curious; I play in a 6×6 ESPN league where the only “limits” per se are total number of starts made by SP’s. In that regard, I’ve found myself looking at more high OBP multi-positional players, and tend to draft more east coast “starting” batters (all things being relatively equal) so if they’re not in the line-up, I can slot in somebody else with a later starting time. Thought being if your “starter” is a LA based OF’er and all the other games have started before you find out he’s not in the lineup, you can’t move another guy into that slot. (our cats. are R, RBI, AVG, SB, HR, and OBP for batting; since OBP stays fairly static, only the AVG category is non-cumulative, making filling each slot as much as possible every night a critical strategy) Any of you guys stress East Coast batters in that way?
I play Yahoo leagues, I’ve never heard anyone say anything terribly positive about ESPN, so I’ve never investigated.
Yahoo hasn’t supported that sort of style in the past. If it did I would definitely employ a similar approach. Currently, if I have an east coast guy and he doesn’t make his expected start, he’s still locked into that roster spot.
I’m kind of glad it’s done that way. I already spend too much time micromanaging.
My thoughts:
I think I see every negative when it comes to David Wright. Needless to say I won’t be drafting him. It’s probably just a relic of my days as a Mets hater, but he seems to get substantially worse every season.
I think A-Rod has a couple full seasons left in the tank. Being able to take on DH duties from time to time could help. Putting him ahead of Wright is probably silly, but that’s how I would draft.
There is a CLIFF after Youkilis/Young. Solve your 3b situation in the first 10 picks or don’t solve it at all.
I’m the only one with McGehee love apparently. Thinking back, I didn’t adjust for park or the likely platoon he’ll end up in. That’s a ranking that could change quickly with spring training information.
And the McGehee love is a condemnation of the position. I’m pretty sure he didn’t rank in my top 250.
McGehee isn’t in my top 250 or 300 for that matter. I want to say the Pirates have already said that the third base job is Alvarez’ to lose. I’m not going anywhere near except as a bench play in AL only leagues.
Yeah, I knew I read it.
http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/sports/pirates/s_779697.html
And in all fairness Brad, there’s two big names possibly three gaining eligibility early on which should help solidify the position a bit (Hanley, Cabrera, and Trumbo)
John,
I’m definitely familiar with the approach. During the season, I have a side job that puts me in an an office at a computer right around the start of the East coast games. So, I’m able to check my starting line-ups a few minutes before game time and make needed swaps to fill out any rest day DNPs.
But, here are my thoughts on this –
1. Unless you are hyper diligent about this, I don’t think this consideration is worth paying much attention to on draft day. It’s a strategy that gets you marginal advantage over the season, but I don’t know if it really tips the scales in favor of anybody. The best thing I can say about it is that it helps mitigate concern over rostering balky veterans prone to nagging injuries who require more random off days than the average player.
2. I’m not sure there’s much of a East/West factor at play anyway though. If you check before East coast start time, what you need is a back-up option. You could have another east coast player on the bench who is starting who you can rotate in. Further, your west coast sub could get a day off too.
3. There’s some general talk about using this strategy specifically for catchers in the catchers ranking thread – seeing as Cs are the most common pseudo-random DNP position. You might want to read through that as some of the points made specifically about C-platoons are somewhat broadly applicable to the strategy at large.
Can those whom wanketh the Lawrie hype chain the hardest take a deep breath and come home to reality please?
I’m afraid Hanley’s wonky shoulder is gonna fall off. Therefore, though I have him as the #3 SS, I’d never take him.
I never liked malingerers anyways.