State of the AL Central: pennant home stretch edition


We’re in the home stretch, and the race for the AL Central is still anything but decided. Well, if you’re in Kansas City, Minnesota, or Cleveland, it’s been decided. Those teams have fallen out of contention over the course of the season.

But the Tigers and White Sox are still locked in a dogfight as the season approaches its end. Thus, it sure is going to be a fun week as the White Sox host the Tigers for a four-game series in Chicago. Obviously, that series will go a long way in determining who wins the division.

And winning the division is really key because, as it currently stands, neither the Sox nor Tigers would get a Wild Card. In fact, heading into yesterday, the third-place team in both the AL East and AL West had a better record than any team in the AL Central.

So let’s take a gander at the AL Central teams, one by one.

Chicago White Sox

They weren’t supposed to be the best team in the division, but the ChiSox have been atop the standings most of the year, including nearly the entire time since Memorial Day. That said, while they have a lead, it’s never been a safe lead, peaking at 3.5 games, and that was back in mid-July.

It all comes down to starting pitching; the Sox will win or lose with it. If the starters hold up, the Sox will be division champs. If they flounders, they won’t. Normally, that would be a good thing for Chicago as starting pitching probably has been the franchise’s strongest feature in the 21st century. Also, it’s been very good for much of 2012. But the question marks surrounding the staff are pretty substantial at the moment.

Let’s start with Jake Peavy. The injury-prone ex-Padres star was a wild card entering into this season, but he’s delivered. He has an ERA of 3.22 with six Quality Starts in his last eight outings.

Sale: Chicago’s ace so far this year

For most teams, Peavy would be the ace, but the best Chicago pitcher this year has been Chris Sale. Here’s where we start running into some concerns. While Sale has been great, averaging a strikeout per inning with an ERA under 3.00, he hasn’t been himself of late.

From the All-Star break up to this weekend, Sale’s ERA was 4.18. There are some serious concerns that the kid is worn out in his first full season as a big league starter.

Clearly the Sox think so, as they had Sale skip a start in early August, and rumors swirl that it will happen again. Then again, just this Saturday, Sale pitched a gem, allowing just one run in six innings.

If Sale is ineffective or has to miss a start, things get a bit trickier. Normally, the Sox have a nice one-two punch of workmanlike starters to rely on with Gavin Floyd and John Danks.

This duo has helped solidify the team’s rotation for the last few years, but this season has been a disaster for both. They’ve combined for just 12 wins and a 4.88 ERA. They’ve also both been hampered with injuries. Danks is out for the year, and Floyd currently is on the shelf with a dinged elbow.

At the trade deadline, the Sox made an interesting move to shore up their starting pitching depth by landing Minnesota’s Francisco Liriano. He’s been a disappointment, allowing 27 walks and 40 hits in 40.2 innings for a 5.03 ERA.

The shining salvation for the team’s second-half struggles in filling out its rotation has been 23-year-old rookie Jose Quintana. Part of what was reputedly the worst farm system in baseball, Quintana had a great early summer, but since the All-Star break he’s had his troubles. In his last 10 starts, he’s struck out fewer than a batter every two innings while lasting under six innings a game and posting an ERA of 5.31.

Ultimately, the White Sox have a rotation full of question marks, and it looks shakier now than it has all year. Still, Quintana could get his groove back, Liriano does have nice stuff (he’s actually fanning over a batter per inning despite his troubles in Chicago), Sale could hold up, and Floyd could come back and do fine. Could, could, could … if enough of those coulds becomes dids, the Sox will hold on.

The Sox do have a great pitching coach in Don Cooper. They have a better run differential than their opposition. Also, they have more home games. But nothing is certain.

A Hardball Times Update
Goodbye for now.

Detroit Tigers

For Detroit, like Chicago, starting pitching is of vital importance. Unlike Chicago, however, it’s getting stronger instead of shakier as we head down the stretch.

The big improvements have come from Max Scherzer and Doug Fister. In the first half of the year, Scherzer was an enigma. He fanned over 120 batters in under 100 innings—normally a pretty damn good sign for a pitcher—but couldn’t get anyone out otherwise. Sure, Detroit has a bad defense, but Scherzer was especially snake-bit.

Since mid-July, Scherzer has been great. In his last 10 starts, he’s still fanning a ton, while his homers allowed rate has been cut in half, and with it his ERA has also tumbled: 2.37 in 68.2 innings. Reports have come out that he dealt with a family tragedy earlier this year (the suicide of his brother), and either he’s gotten past that or the laws of Voros McCracken have finally broken in his favor.

Scherzer is keeping Detriot’s hopes alive.

Fister also has pitched far better since the All-Star break. His ERA was 4.75 before, but it’s down to 2.48 since then. His recent success is a little flukish in that he’s allowing a homer every 16 innings, and that’s not sustainable. Then again, Fister is fanning his share of batters and walking very few, so he should keep pitching well.

Oh yeah, they also have Justin Verlander. Perhaps you’ve heard of him. Rumor has it, he’s pretty good. Actually, he’s been roughed up pretty good in two of his last three starts, but do you really want to bet against Justin Verlander?

Rounding out the rotation, Detroit has Anibal Sanchez, whom the Tigers acquired from the Marlins in midseason. He sucked in his first four starts put been pretty good in his last three. Rick Porcello is the other starter, and he’s serviceable, which is a lot better than most team’s fifth starters.

In all, the Tigers staff is clicking on all cylinders lately. Even if Fister falls back and Sanchez pitches like the league-average arm he’s been for the last several years, the rotation is still far better than it’s been for most of the season. All of this puts that much more pressure on Chicago’s increasingly queasy starting staff.

To date, one other key to staying in the division race for Detroit has been simple: playing head-to-head against Chicago.

On July 20, the White Sox came to Detroit for a three-game series. The Tigers swept them to reverse a game-and-a-half deficit into a game-and-a-half lead. Then Detroit immediately flopped while the Sox got hot, allowing Chicago to quickly move into first again.

But Chicago came back to Detroit on Aug. 31 with a seemingly safe three-game lead. Three games resulted in three more Tigers victories, and Detroit’s second straight sweep put them tied with Chicago. And then, the next day, Detroit lost to Cleveland while Chicago won, putting Chicago back in sole possession of first.

It must be frustrating for the Tigers to keep falling back into second as soon as Chicago leaves town, but the good news is they have won those six games. Without them, Detroit’s chances would be much more slender. It’s also something worthy pondering heading into the big four-game Tigers-White Sox series this week.

Immediately after sweeping the White Sox last time, the Tigers got to play the Indians, who had been the worst-slumping team in the league. Cleveland took two of three from Detroit. That was the first time the Indians had won a series in over a month. That previous Indians series victory was also against the Tigers. Those are the only two series the Indians have won since the All-Star break.

Cleveland is Detroit’s anti-Chicago. If Detroit’s success against the White Sox has kept the Tigers in the race, their inexplicable failures against Cleveland have kept them in second place.

Kansas City Royals

Back in April, the Royals had a 12-game losing streak. Since then, they’ve been about a .500 team. From April 25 on, they’ve been 59-62. It’s not good, but it’s a lot better than we’ve come to expect from the Royals. It’s virtually the same record as the Phillies and Dodgers in that time, and the Royals are the one playing in the tougher league. KC even had winning record in May, June, and August (but were 7-19 in July).

Don’t look now, but the Royals might be a good team next year. Every single member of their starting nine offensive players is in his 20s this year and will be again next year. All the key members of their bullpen, which has been fantastic for them this year, also are in their 20s.

The Royals’ problem is starting pitching, which really has been horrible. The good news is that the easiest way to improve a team is to have an obvious hole that needs filling. The Royals have plenty of holes in their rotation, and so if the rest holds up next year, they can be a surprise.

Then again, the downside for the Royals is that the quality of a bullpen can veer wildly from year to year. It’s the least consistent part of a game. And it’s damn hard to image KC’s relief core will be as good next year as it is this year. Still, the laughing stock of the last decade now looks like a possible dark horse for 2013.

Cleveland Indians

Manny Acta has had a close view of Cleveland’s extended debacle.

Call it the Revenge of Pythagoras. For months, the Indians hung around the race despite having among the worst run differentials in baseball. They kept winning the close ones, even if they couldn’t win any other games.

Remember when Cleveland was in the race? The Indians were in first place in late June and just three games out of first as recently as July 23. They ended August in fourth place, 22 games under .500.

How the hell does that happen? Easy, you have the worst month in the entire history of the franchise. In August, the Indians won five games while losing 24. That tops the old record set in June 1914, when the Indians went 6-24.

Forget monthly records for a second. August was the centerpiece of a 5-28 stretch for the Indians. As it happens, that’s the worst 33-game stretch in franchise history. Yippee.

They went 6-27 in 1991, and 7-26 several times, but never in their 112 seasons had the dropped 28 of 33—until now.

Cleveland’s pitching fell apart, averaging over six runs per game in the team’s death spiral. The hurlers allowed four runs or more 24 times in that span—and lost all 24 games.

No wonder the Indians haven’t won three straight since the Fourth of July.

Minnesota Twins

There isn’t too much to say about the Twins. Odds are, they won’t lose 100 games, so they have that going for them. Then again, they way they’ve been playing lately, they just might do it anyway. After beating the Indians in back-to-back games on Aug. 6-7, the Twins lost 21 of their next 28 contests.

They still have some games left against the Indians, Royals, and Blue Jays, so the Twins should avoid their first triple-digit loss season in three decades. But they have also safely claimed the mantle as the worst team in the league. Well, as safe as any such claim can be the way the Indians have been playing lately.

Looking forward

For much of the year, Chicago’s looked like the better team. The Sox had the better record, the better run differential, and plenty of solid contributors.

While they still have a better record and run differential, the gap has closed, and Detroit has been playing more solidly.

Let’s throw one last little feature into the mix: strength of schedule. After their big four-game showdown this week, each team will have 19 games left to play. Frankly, both squads face fairly easy schedules, but it’s easier for the Tigers. The average winning percentage of remaining White Sox opponents is .472, but it’s a meager .450 for the Tigers. That breaks in Detroit’s favor.

Right now, I’d pick Detroit to win it all, but it’s a shaky prediction. It’s tough to know how the race will shake up, especially with that big four-game Tigers-Sox series going down this weekend.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Selling Jeans
10 years ago

i’ve been described, given the seeming easy schedule of all the games against CLEV, MINN and TB, about how mediocre both these teams have been as of late. Could it be an unintended consequence of the new playoff format, for while BALT, TB, OAK, and LAA have all had to keep winning to stay in WC contention, both the Sox and the Tigers know, like the two guys being chased by a bear, they just have to beat each other to get in. And they get a real series, not a 1 game gimmick, to boot.

selling jeans
10 years ago

sorry—meant to say “surprised”, not “described”. I’m as bad as these two teams are!!

Detroit Michael
10 years ago

I don’t think one can blame Scherzer’s bad results earlier in the year on his brother’s death:  the timing doesn’t work out at all.  (You only hinted at that possibility, I realize.)

10 years ago

It seems neither team wants to take this division.  Except for the Tigers beating the White Sox regularly, neither team is playing all that well.  If they both had been playing just average then the loser could be looking at a wild card.  If one of them had been playing decent then that team would have a pretty comfortable lead and this four game series would be do-or-die.  As it is, I think you are right.  The White Sox are holding their starting rotation together with duct tape and the Tigers are getting quality starting pitching.  Unless that changes, I don’t see how the White Sox can hold on.

Also, Lifting up Jose Quintana as a shining example of why the White Sox farm system doesn’t suck is actually a pretty good example of why it does.  They didn’t really develop him.  He spent only 9 starts and 48 innings in their system and still was the best they had available as a sixth starter when they needed one.  He’s been a pleasant surprise, but the fact that they had nothing else better just shows how bad they are.  In fact, an extroardinarily low number of players on the roster have spent more than a year in their minor league system and almost all of those are relivers or bench players.  Of the rotation and starting lineup, only DeAza, Viciedo and (sorta starter) Santiago have spent as much as a full year in the minor league system.  Not good.

White Sox Fan Brother
10 years ago

Well, after last night, perhaps Quintana got his groove back.

Also, Floyd has been penciled in as the starter on Wednesday.  Of course, he’s been anything but reliable this year, so it remains to be seen whether it’s a good thing or not.

Roy in Omaha
10 years ago

The cacophony of complainers about the Royals starting pitching ALL seem to continually overlook the fact that the Royals pitching staff, as a whole, is far, far closer to league average than the offense has been this season. The Royals offense is closing on being historically bad from a franchise perspective. Besides the Royals being last (by far) in walks drawn in the major leagues, last in the AL in home runs, and 10th in the AL in runs scored, the Royals are on a pace to score 688 runs this season. That would be the 11th worst total in franchise history throwing out strike seasons and they wouldn’t have to score very many fewer runs to finish as low on that list as 6th, instead of 11th, either.

They aren’t pitching nearly as poorly as they are hitting. If the Royals had even a league average offense in terms of runs scored this season they Pythagorean out at right around .500 this season.

If the Royals were around the .500 mark or so I think a lot of people would be looking at them in a totally different light.