Nationals make great deal for Fister

On Monday night, news broke that the Tigers had traded starting pitcher Doug Fister to the the Washington Nationals for utility man Steve Lombardozzi, reliever Ian Krol, and pitching prospect Robbie Ray, according to Chris Cotillo. This one raised many eyebrows because it came out of nowhere and also because of the seemingly small return going to Detroit.

Fister, 30 in February, is coming off a year in which he pitched to a 3.67 ERA (3.26 FIP) in 208.2 innings and 32 starts. It should be noted that this is Fister’s highest ERA since 2010, which could be attributed to a .332 BABIP, 34 points above his career average. When you combine all of this with a very nice groundball rate, you would think making the switch out of Comerica shouldn’t hurt him too much. It should also be noted that he’s missed a start here and there, but he’s still managed to throw at least 160 innings in each of the last four years.

Fister will be going through his second year arbitration this year and Matt Swartz projects him to make a very reasonable $6.9 million. He’s not due to become a free agent until after the 2015 season. It’s a very good addition to a starting rotation that already ranked sixth in the majors in FIP last year.

As far as the Tigers side of the trade goes, I’m not sure I get it. They gave up a mid-rotation starter (which is pretty valuable these days if you take a look at the free agent market) and got back a couple of extra pieces and a pitching prospect. I understand that they wanted to free up a spot for Drew Smyly to start, but I thought they would have been able to fetch a bit more.

However, Tigers general manager Dave Dombrowski has a very good track record with trades (Max Scherzer, Austin Jackson, etc.) and we’ve seen that they’re looking for more financial flexibility (as we saw from the Prince Fielder trade), so I guess we’ll have to see. But for now, it looks like Washington is getting the better of this one.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
10 years ago

i don’t read the papers so I don’t know what the local take is on this. My “take” is based on close observation during the last couple seasons. The trade is a good one for Detroit, although I wished they could get a catcher. Anyway, to be successful, Fister has to have all his pitches working, particularly his “swing-back” fastball, and without all his pitches he is game, but can’t actually win. In fact, he’s too iffy when he’s off, although he manages to keep the team in the game, usually. He is a 4th or 5th guy and will do well in Washington provided they do not rely on him providing a bunch of wins. He is similar to Doyle Alexander, in that he’s tall, has a lot of pitches, but once you look at everything, he’s pretty ordinary. His career record is not much. The team had to keep Porcello and that is excellent. He’s 25 and is just now learning that he’s good enough to control a game. His post-All Star game outings were bulldog efforts and he should’ve pitched in the postseason. He is really deserving of an elevated chance.  He has a lot of upside. Examining the people the team acquired: Lombardozzi can run and will replace Santiago; the lefthanders – one is a prospect. Let’s say he’s no good, so he’s out. The other one pitched for the Nationals with moderate success. He’s young and cheaper. he will replace the “Smyly” role in the pen, if not the Coke role. Other than not getting a catcher, the team has done very well in the offseason so far.

10 years ago

In agreement of looks and style, however, you would be hard-pressed to acquaint the aberration amid broad handbags modeled afterwards artist handbags and the artist handbags themselves.