Top 10 prospects for 2010: Tampa Bay Rays and Baltimore Orioles

Tampa Bay Rays

1. Desmond Jennings: As one of the most dynamic players in minor league baseball, Jennings represents the future leadoff hitter for a Tampa Bay organization hoping to compete year after year.
2. Jeremy Hellickson: He is a control artist with the repertoire of a mid-rotation starter. However, improved movement and an uptick in his secondary offerings could lead to even greater things. If Hellickson can stay healthy, he is the most sure thing that Tampa Bay has to offer.
3. Wade Davis: His overall repertoire has ace written all over it, but Davis’ control needs to improve across the board if he’s going successfully transition to the big leagues.
4. Matthew Moore: Representing the third true potential No. 1 starter in Tampa Bay’s farm system, Moore has fantastic stuff but needs to improve his control if he’s going to succeed at higher levels. He still has a ways to go.
5. Tim Beckham: He was an overdraft at No. 1 in the 2008 draft, but there is no denying his upside. As a true work in progress, his glove needs just as much improvement as his bat.
6. Reid Brignac: You would like to see him cement his play in the major leagues, but Brignac has a little bit of everything you look for in an everyday shortstop. A very solid player is in the works.
7. Nick Barnese: His stuff doesn’t turn heads, but Barnese has all the makings of a mid-rotation big-league starter. It’s doubtful at this point, but if one of his secondary pitches develops into a truly dominant “out” pitch, even greater things could be on the horizon.
8. Jake McGee: Back from Tommy John surgery, McGee threw limited innings in 2009. His goal in 2010 will be to recover what he had before the surgery, namely his plus fastball. Tampa may move him to the bullpen permanently, but I’m still willing to invest.
9. Kyle Lobstein: His reputation gets a bit overblown at times, but there is no denying Lobstein’s deliberate mechanics and solid repertoire. I do have to question how much projection is left in his arm, however.
10. Cody Rogers: Offering considerable upside, Rogers quietly put together a fantastic Appy League debut. He needs a lot of refinement, but he has a nice combination of power and speed to go along with his natural contact skills.

Baltimore Orioles

1. Brian Matusz: Matusz has everything you look for in a front-of-the-rotation prospect, including an arsenal full of potentially plus pitches, a feel for the type of control it takes to succeed in the big leagues, and an intimidating demeanor on the mound.
2. Jake Arrieta: He has an average four-pitch mix and a fastball that can occasionally touch the mid-90s, but it is time to question Arrieta’s endurance. It’s the only thing holding back his No. 2 starter upside.
3. Brandon Erbe: Erbe sports impressive stuff, but he doesn’t possess an out pitch and, frankly, he is far too hittable right now. His control is not where it needs to be either. He is more raw than he should be at his point, and he looks like a mid-rotation starter.
4. Matt Hobgood: With great endurance and advanced movement for his age, Hobgood has a good amount of upside. His repertoire has a long maturation process ahead, though.
5. Zach Britton: His groundball rate and natural, sinking action are his best assets, but Britton doesn’t have enough ability to miss bats, which will become more apparent as he moves through the system.
6. Josh Bell: Bell’s home run power busted out in 2009, but his overall upside is not indicative of his numbers. He has the makings of an average third baseman with his strong eye, solid contact skills and above-average power.
7. Xavier Avery: Avery is an eye-catching ballplayer. His raw playmaking ability is something every team craves, but the numerous holes in his swing and lousy plate patience have forced me to be patient.
8. Mychal Givens: Givens is a tremendous athlete with a killer arm at shortstop. He needs a lot of refinement in both his offensive and defensive game. He has a long way to go in order to obtain the smoothness needed to succeed as a line-drive-hitting shortstop.
9. Brandon Snyder: If Snyder weren’t a first baseman, his bat would be playable at the major league level. But his offense projects as below average as a first baseman. More development is needed, but his bat could be maxed out.
10. Ryan Adams: With some upside left, Adams has the contact skills to play at higher levels, but the question is whether or not his power, speed and patience will ever develop into usable skills at the same time.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jeff V.
14 years ago

Wow, that is an interesting take on the O’s top 10.  A few comments:
#2 Arrieta-Endurance?  I don’t think its endurance thats the problem, its that his slider and changeup are “hard” and folks at the higher levels are timing his stuff the second and third time through the order.  He is also in love with the strikeout which runs up his pitch count.  Honestly I think he ends up as a closer when it is all said and done.

#5- Britton you really have him behind Erbe and Hobgood?  What has Hobgood done except be drafted 1-5?  Have you looked at Britton’s K rate in the minors?  What basis do you have for expecting his ability to miss bats to drop sharply?

#7 and 8- Are you just raking these guys off of thier draft position?  They are both very raw and Givens might project better as a bullpen arm.

#9- Really #9 for Snyder?  With the notable exception of Norfolk, where Snyder admits he changed his approach at the plate, Snyder has been tearing up leagues for the past season.  He tore up winter ball, he tore up the eastern league and he is doing very well in the AFL as I type.  He does not have prototypical power at first base but he is a pure hitter.  Snyder will play in the big leagues which is something you can not say with any certaintly about Givens and Avery.

14 years ago

As I recall, Tim Beckham was supposed to be a kind of toolsy shortstop that might move to 2B as he moved up. I’m not sure if that’s accurate or not, but what kind of power are we expecting to see from him? Is he supposed to develop into a speedy, OBP kind of guy, or more of a power threat in the lineup?

14 years ago

I think your rankings for the O’s are spot on. You consider upside more than production at the minor league level. Which is what I like to see in a prospect report. I especially like the Mychal Givens ranking. I feel a lot of O’s fans got to hung up on his bonus demands. This guy was projected as a high round pick after the 08 draft. He has more upside than most fans think.

Jeff V.
14 years ago

Justin, he is 19 and he was playing in Tampa, there is no excuse for him not to be a polished player for someone coming out of HS. 

Yes he has tools but he also hung out with friends after getting drafted instead of working on his game. 

He is a bit sloppy in the field and there are serious questions about if his bat plays at the major league level.  However he does have a nice mid 90’s fastball coming out of a deceptive arm slot.

My guess is the O’s give him one, maybe two seasons to be an everyday player, then fast track him to the bullpen.

14 years ago

O’s prospect rankings should go like this:

1 – Matusz – legit Ace potential
2 – Bell – you are greatly underrating his potential
3 – Arrieta – future closer or #2
4 – Britton – future innings eater
5 – Snyder – will not hit 30HR, but .300 with 20 will do at 1B.  Great RBI guy
6 – Erbe – great raw stuff
7 – Waring – did you see his breakout 2009?
8 – Steve Johnson – underrated prospect in the Sherrill deal with legit #3 SP upside
9 – Avery – great pure athlete
10 – Givens – has great upside at pitcher or SS

14 years ago

I don’t think Hobgood deserves a spot near the top 5 at this point. Josh Bell is overrated and I’m glad you picked up on that. Peter B.—Brandon Waring isn’t a top 10 prospect no matter how you cut it.

14 years ago

What about Chris Tillman?  Or is he not considered a prospect any more?

14 years ago

I have Half of there autographs

13 years ago

BK, having the autographs of half the team will not making them any better players, lol!! The O’s are good and powerful but the Ray’s aren’t any lower than them. Both the teams are equally strong and will surely have a tough battle once the game is set between them. I look forward for Matusz to lead the game this time. He surely is a trump card or lets triumph card! – Jordan

Shop Jerseys
13 years ago

thank you very much to sharing this information.